☸️ GOLD MEDAL ☸️ Kill both of the Foreman boys yourself during the chase Complete with at least 90% accuracy

No, No and Thrice, No

If losing Jack isn't enough, now Tilly is missing. Grimshaw knows it was her former gang so they need to save her before it's too late.

Rewards: Loot

Good, bad, and ugly

Mary-Beth is reading at her tent. She tells Arthur how the gang has cared for her when no one else did. Her mother died of typhoid a while ago so she had a rough road. She asks about Mary but Arthur doesn't have much to say about that. Susan Grimshaw comes over and tells Arthur that Tilly was captured by her former gang the Foreman Brothers. Susan grabs her gun and takes Arthur with her. They hop on a wagon.

Drive to Radley's House. Susan says Tilly knew this camp was near one of the places her old gang uses. She didn't think it would be a problem but now it is. Arthur thinks it was a Foreman Brother hassling Tilly in Valentine. Susan reveals that Tilly had killed one of the Foremans before joining Dutch. Good to know.

No love lost

Pulling up to the house, a guard is outside the front door. Susan pretends to be lost and stabs him. She tells Arthur to go inside and get Tilly. Enter the house however you wish. Inside a Foreman Brother is waiting in the kitchen. Take him out. The front two rooms are empty. In the back room you'll find Tilly with a Foreman Brother. Kill him and cut tilly loose.

Arthur and Susan comfort her. She says the leader - Anthony Foreman - got her. He went out hunting with others. They exit the back of the house as a group flees on horseback. Tilly is told to stand guard. She wants the boss alive for her. Susan jumps on a horse with Arthur. Catch up and kill the henchmen. There are two of them. They run through the trees towards the Clemens Point camp and then back to the main road. Susan isn't the best shot so you can help her out.


After taking out the henchmen, the gang leader is spotted. Use your lasso to take him alive. When you get him, tie Anthony up. Susan takes his horse and rides back to Tilly to check on her. Put Anthony on your horse and go back to Radley's Pasture. Anthony says Tilly killed his cousin and is a liar. He should have killed her when he had the chance. You have the option to hit Anthony during the trip.

Revenge is a fool's game

Back with Tilly and Susan, put Anthony on the ground in front of the house. As Tilly and Susan yell at him, Arthur cuts the rope on Anthony's feet and stands him up with a knife to his throat. Tilly doesn't want him dead. She wants him to tell the rest of his gang to leave her alone. Susan would rather have the dead option but gives Arthur the choice to kill Anthony or let him go. You decide.

Arthur will do as you choose. Susan and Tilly take off in the wagon. If Anthony was allowed to live he will run away. You can loot the house if you wish.

Gold Tips

• There is no time objective so take it easy.
• Wait until you have a clear shot to take out the henchmen. Areas such as crossing the road(s), along the water, or on the path from the old camp. Use Dead Eye to see better and paint your targets.
• There is no headshot objective but try to take out the enemies as quickly as possible, especially during the horseback chase.
• If you want to increase your accuracy count aim for non-lethal parts such as arms or torso. There are only five enemies to get, so one missed shot can set you back.
• Use caution moving through the trees. Your horse doesn't always avoid them as it should.