Red Dead Redemption Hunting Prices

All values manually checked in game by Psy from iRedDead.com. Prices with (H) and with a yellow background are the prices you earn if you have a positive honor rating (Over Peacemaker everywhere but Thieves Landing) OR you have a negative honor rating (Below Road Agent specifically at Thieves Landing). Prices with a grey background are the default prices you'll earn everywhere if your Honor rating is above Road Agent and below Peacemaker.

Special thanks to Asthenia, OptimumPx, Kuwong and ViceMan for assistance with the creation of this guide.

Here are the honor ratings in order from Very Negative to Very Positive so you know where you stand. Just pause the game and look at your stats to find out what you are.
Desperado - Honor Bonus At Thieves' Landing
Road Agent - Honor Bonus At Thieves' Landing
Rustler - No Bonus
Drifter - No Bonus
Honest Joe - No Bonus
Peacemaker - Honor Bonus Everywhere But Thieves' Landing
Hero - Honor Bonus Everywhere But Thieves' Landing

Trading Regions
Frontier: Armadillo, MacFarlane's Ranch, Thieves' Landing
Mexico: Chuparosa, Escalera
North: Blackwater, Manzanita Post

Hunting Prices / Values

Default Prices Honor Bonus
Item Frontier Mexico North Best Price Best Location Frontier (H) Mexico (H) North (H) Best Price (H) Best Location (H)
Butterfly Weed 3 2 4 4 North 5 3 6 6 North
Desert Sage 1 2 2 2 Mexico,North 2 2 2 2 Any
Golden Currant 6 8 4 8 Mexico 9 12 6 12 Mexico
Hummingbird Sage 8 10 5 10 Mexico 11 15 8 15 Mexico
Prairie Poppy 6 8 4 8 Mexico 9 12 6 12 Mexico
Prickly Pear 3 2 4 4 North 5 3 6 6 North
Red Sage 2 2 3 3 North 3 5 5 5 Mexico,North
Violet Snowdrop 9 12 6 12 Mexico 14 18 9 18 Mexico
Wooly Blue Curls 5 3 6 6 North 7 5 9 9 North
Wild Feverfew 1 2 2 2 Mexico,North 2 2 2 2 Any
Armadillo Meat 5 3 6 6 North 7 5 9 9 North
Armadillo Carapace 8 5 10 10 North 11 8 15 15 North
Beaver Meat 8 10 5 10 Mexico 11 15 8 15 Mexico
Beaver Fur 18 24 12 24 Mexico 27 36 18 36 Mexico
Bighorn Meat 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Bighorn Horn 12 12 12 12 Any 18 18 18 18 Any
Bighorn Skin 8 8 8 8 Any 12 12 12 12 Any
Boar Meat 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Boar Skin 3 3 3 3 Any 5 5 5 5 Any
Boar Tusks 8 8 8 8 Any 12 12 12 12 Any
Bobcat Meat 8 5 5 8 Frontier 11 8 8 11 Frontier
Bobcat Claw 18 12 12 18 Frontier 27 18 18 27 Frontier
Bobcat Fur 12 8 8 12 Frontier 18 12 12 18 Frontier
Buck Meat 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Buck Antlers 8 8 8 8 Any 12 12 12 12 Any
Buck Skin 6 6 6 6 Any 9 9 9 9 Any
Buffalo Meat 15 20 10 20 Mexico 23 30 15 30 Mexico
Buffalo Horns 12 16 8 16 Mexico 18 24 12 24 Mexico
Buffalo Skin 18 24 12 24 Mexico 27 36 18 36 Mexico
Chicken Feathers 1 1 1 1 Any 2 2 2 2 Any
Cow Meat 4 4 4 4 Any 6 6 6 6 Any
Cow Hide 4 4 4 4 Any 6 6 6 6 Any
Cougar Meat 5 8 5 8 Mexico 8 11 8 11 Mexico
Cougar Claw 12 18 12 18 Mexico 18 27 18 27 Mexico
Cougar Fang 8 12 8 12 Mexico 12 18 12 18 Mexico
Cougar Pelt 8 12 8 12 Mexico 12 18 12 18 Mexico
Coyote Meat 3 3 3 3 Any 5 5 5 5 Any
Coyote Pelt 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Crow Feathers 3 3 3 3 Any 5 5 5 5 Any
Deer Meat 4 4 4 4 Any 6 6 6 6 Any
Deer Skin 6 6 6 6 Any 9 9 9 9 Any
Dog Meat 1 1 2 2 North 2 2 2 2 Any
Dog Fur 2 2 3 3 North 3 3 5 5 North
Duck Feathers 2 2 2 2 Any 3 3 3 3 Any
Eagle Feathers 8 12 8 12 Mexico 12 18 12 18 Mexico
Elk Meat 8 12 8 12 Mexico 12 18 12 18 Mexico
Elk Antlers 12 18 12 18 Mexico 18 27 18 27 Mexico
Elk Skin 9 14 9 14 Mexico 14 20 14 20 Mexico
Fox Meat 5 8 5 8 Mexico 8 11 8 11 Mexico
Fox Fur 12 18 12 18 Mexico 18 27 18 27 Mexico
Goat Meat 5 5 8 8 North 8 8 11 11 North
Grizzly Meat 12 16 8 16 Mexico 18 24 12 24 Mexico
Grizzly Claw 12 16 8 16 Mexico 18 24 12 24 Mexico
Grizzly Tooth 18 24 12 24 Mexico 27 36 18 36 Mexico
Grizzly Furs 18 24 12 24 Mexico 27 36 18 36 Mexico
Grizzly Heart 24 32 16 32 Mexico 36 48 24 48 Mexico
Seagull Feathers 3 2 2 3 Frontier 5 3 3 5 Frontier
Hawk Feathers 6 6 6 6 Any 9 9 9 9 Any
Mule Hide 2 1 2 2 Frontier,North 2 2 2 2 Any
Mule Meat 2 1 2 2 Frontier,North 2 2 2 2 Any
Lobo's Meat 48 64 32 64 Mexico 72 96 48 96 Mexico
Lobo's Heart 66 88 44 88 Mexico 99 132 66 132 Mexico
Lobo's Fur 72 96 48 96 Mexico 108 144 72 144 Mexico
Brumas' Meat 54 72 36 72 Mexico 81 108 54 108 Mexico
Brumas' Teeth 66 88 44 88 Mexico 99 132 66 132 Mexico
Brumas' Claw 48 64 32 64 Mexico 72 96 48 96 Mexico
Brumas' Heart 54 72 36 72 Mexico 81 108 54 108 Mexico
Brumas' Fur 72 96 48 96 Mexico 108 144 72 144 Mexico
Khan's Meat 48 32 64 64 North 72 48 96 96 North
Khan's Pelt 36 24 48 48 North 54 36 72 72 North
Khan's Fang 63 42 84 84 North 95 63 126 126 North
Khan's Heart 54 36 72 72 North 81 54 108 108 North
Gordo's Meat 32 48 64 64 North 48 72 96 96 North
Gordo's Tusks 36 54 54 54 Mexico,North 54 81 81 81 Mexico,North
Gordo's Skin 36 54 54 54 Mexico,North 54 81 81 81 Mexico,North
Gordo's Heart 48 72 72 72 Mexico,North 72 108 108 108 Mexico,North
Owl Feathers 4 4 4 4 Any 6 6 6 6 Any
Pig Meat 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Rabbit Meat 3 3 3 3 Any 5 5 5 5 Any
Raccoon Meat 3 5 3 5 Mexico 5 7 5 7 Mexico
Raccoon Fur 5 8 5 8 Mexico 8 11 8 11 Mexico
Skunk Meat 3 3 3 3 Any 5 5 5 5 Any
Skunk Fur 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Snake Skin 6 6 6 6 Any 9 9 9 9 Any
Songbird Feather 5 5 5 5 Any 8 8 8 8 Any
Vulture Feathers 3 3 3 3 Any 5 5 5 5 Any
Wolf Meat 8 8 8 8 Any 12 12 12 12 Any
Wolf Pelt 10 10 10 10 Any 15 15 15 15 Any
Wolf Heart 12 12 12 12 Any 18 18 18 18 Any
Horse Meat 2 2 2 2 Any 3 3 3 3 Any
Horse Hide 2 2 2 2 Any 3 3 3 3 Any
Rhode's Gold 100 100 100 100 Any 150 150 150 150 Any
Jackson's Gold 125 125 125 125 Any 188 188 188 188 Any
Calhoun's Gold 150 150 150 150 Any 225 225 225 225 Any
Tubman's Gold 175 175 175 175 Any 263 263 263 263 Any
Brown's Gold 200 200 200 200 Any 300 300 300 300 Any
Douglass' Gold 225 225 225 225 Any 338 338 338 338 Any
Garrison's Gold 300 300 300 300 Any 450 450 450 450 Any
Pickett's Gold 400 400 400 400 Any 600 600 600 600 Any
Stonewall's Gold 500 500 500 500 Any 750 750 750 750 Any