Skip to content
iRedDead.com
Navigation
Home What's New? Forum Games News Info Guides Maps Images Videos Downloads
User

Welcome, Guest. If you have an account, please log in below.

Login
Register

Need an account? Registration is now open!

Create an Account
iRedDead.com
Red Dead RedemptionRed Dead Redemption - Side Mission Guide

Who Are You to Judge?

Published by TreeFitty
Last Updated by Psy

A man is crazy about his love who was taken by bandits. He is grateful for any help towards her return.

There are 3 parts to this mission.

Part 1

REQUIREMENTS:

LOCATION:

WALKTHROUGH:

Speak to a man named Jeb in Rathskeller Fork.

He's sitting on some hay near the stables.

He's extremely upset because the love of his life was taken by gangsters from Tumbleweed.

He pleads endlessly for help getting his love back.

Marston agrees to help.

You're then told to "Look for Jeb's love in Tumbleweed".

Part 2

REQUIREMENTS:

  • Must have completed "Who Are You To Judge?" Part 1.

LOCATION:

WALKTHROUGH:

Head down to Tumbleweed which is a gang hideout but may be inactive when you approach. On the north side, find a woman with a horse near the roadway in a small old stable.

When she's told that her man misses her dearly, she says her man was shot by lawmen a month ago. The confusion is cleared up when it's revealed that the horse, named Lucy, is Jeb's girl.

The woman took the horse off him a week ago but agrees to return it to Jeb.

Head back to Rathskeller Fork with the woman and Lucy following.

The woman laughs at your confusion and assumptions of Jeb's sanity during the ride.

As you approach Rathskeller Fork, this part will be complete and the game will autosave.

Part 3

REQUIREMENTS:

  • Must have completed "Who Are You To Judge?" Part 2.

LOCATION:

WALKTHROUGH:

Once back in the village go over to Jeb.

He's very thankful to have his girl back.

As Jeb expresses his love, the woman comments that her father was similar with goats.

Tips

  • This stranger mission is easy.
  • Sneak into the area from the north to avoid enemies if needed. Speak to the woman and leave the way you came in.
  • You should be able to sprint back with no issues. If you get separated the woman will meet you at the entrance to the village.
  • Keep an eye on the Newspaper later in the game... Turns out Jeb and the love of his life got married in a small and unconventional ceremony. Who are you to judge anyway?

Mission Rewards

  • +100 Honor

100% Completion

Story Missions

New Austin
Intro
Bonnie MacFarlane
Marshall Johnson
Nigel West Dickens
Seth Briars
Irish
Nuevo Paraiso
Irish
Vicente De Santa
Landon Ricketts
Luisa Fortuna
Abraham Reyes
West Elizabeth
Edgar Ross
Harold MacDougal
Homestead
Abigail Marston
Uncle
Jack Marston

Stranger Side-Missions

Side Objectives

Other Guides

This guide has been viewed 15,517 times. Thanks for your support!